Top 5 CDs Worth Your Time (Nov 1)
Big rate. Real terms. Mostly clean fine print. Our take on First Heritage CD's 5.05% APY certificate of deposit after two weeks of testing.
CDs · First Heritage CD
As of November 1, 2025 · APY
What we liked
- Auto-renewal can be turned off in the customer portal
- 5.05% APY APY is real for the disclosed term
- Brokered version available with same headline rate
- Early-withdrawal penalty is industry-standard, no hidden fees
Watch outs
- Early-withdrawal penalty applies even in financial hardship
- Brokered version requires existing brokerage account
When we rebuilt our CD ladder for the spring, First Heritage CD held two rungs — the 12-month at 5.05% APY and the 24-month at a slightly lower headline rate. Here's why both still earn the spot.
When this CD makes sense
If you have cash that doesn't need to be liquid for the next 12 months and your HYSA is paying within 0.30 of First Heritage CD's 5.05% APY, the CD wins on a tax-equivalent basis only if you're in a 22%+ federal bracket and intend to roll. Below that, a high-yield savings account at near-parity rate is the better pick because the optionality is free.
Compared to T-Bills
On a 12-month basis, First Heritage CD's 5.05% APY CD is roughly tied with the auctioned T-Bill rate net-of-state-tax in most jurisdictions. In states with high income tax, the T-Bill wins because Treasury interest is state-tax-exempt. In low-tax states, the CD wins on liquidity (settlement is faster than rolling a Treasury auction).
The early-withdrawal math
Three months of interest at 5.05% APY on a $10,000 deposit is roughly $135. That's the real cost of breaking the CD early. If you think there's any chance you'll need the cash before maturity, the no-penalty CD at First Heritage CD (currently 4.81) is the better trade — you give up some yield for the option to walk.
How we tested
We opened a soft-pull control account at First Heritage CD and walked the application flow for the 5.05% APY 12-month CD. The application disclosed: a $1,000 minimum, no maintenance fee, an early-withdrawal penalty of 3 months interest, and automatic renewal at the prevailing rate (which we don't love, but it's the industry standard). We did not actually fund. The disclosed APY held throughout.
What's next on the floor
First Heritage CD's 5.05% APY stays on the certificate of deposit watchlist for the next two weeks. We'll re-pull rates Sunday night and post any meaningful change in the next Weekly Rate Floor. If you've used First Heritage CD recently and your experience differed from what we wrote here, drop a comment below — we read everything that lands on the floor.
- Carla R.Nov 3, 2025★★★★★5.0
Solid breakdown. I went with First Heritage CD two weeks ago and the experience tracked exactly with this review.
- Rajiv N.Nov 4, 2025★★★★★4.0
I tried to do this loan with my regular bank first. Went with First Heritage CD after my regular bank ghosted me for a week.
- Sophie B.Nov 4, 2025
The ladder math is exactly the spreadsheet I built three months ago. Glad someone published it.
- Devon S.Nov 5, 2025
Article skips over the AVM waiver criteria. Mine got pulled despite a strong AVM read.
- L. HoltzNov 6, 2025
Anyone tried this on a multi-family conforming? My LO at First Heritage CD said the rate adjustment is 0.50, not the 0.25 the website implies.
- Aleks T.Nov 6, 2025★★★★★5.0
0% APR offer was real but the transfer took five days to post. Plan around that.
- F. MendezNov 7, 2025★★★★★5.0
The ladder math is exactly the spreadsheet I built three months ago. Glad someone published it.
- Kelly H.Nov 7, 2025
Customer service has been hit or miss for me — three callbacks before I got a real answer on the rate sheet.
- Jenna L.Nov 7, 2025★★★★★4.0
I'm a First Heritage CD customer of three years. The HYSA rate held, but they cut my CD renewal rate by 0.40 last month without much notice.
Liked this read?
Subscribe to The Weekly Rate Floor — every Monday, the top three rates worth your time, the one to skip, and the loan window we think is closing.